LazySusan vs Gemini Advanced: Escape Google's Walled Garden
Google's AI Is Great. Google's Lock-In Is Not.
Last updated: January 2025
91
Overall Score
76
Overall Score
Google's Gemini Advanced is legitimately impressive. Native multimodality, deep Google Workspace integration, real-time information, massive context window—it's a serious AI product. At $20/month (bundled with Google One), it seems like great value. But there's a catch nobody talks about: you're not just buying AI. You're buying deeper into Google's ecosystem. Here's why that matters.
Gemini's Real Strengths
Credit where due: Gemini 2.0 Ultra is a technical marvel. It understands images, video, and audio natively—not as bolted-on features. Google Search integration means genuinely current information. Workspace integration lets it work directly in Docs, Sheets, and Gmail. The 1M token context window is insane. If you're already deep in Google's ecosystem, Gemini Advanced is seamless. That's its biggest strength AND its biggest problem.
The Lock-In Nobody Mentions
Every Gemini feature pulls you deeper into Google. NotebookLM requires Google Docs. The best Gemini features require Workspace. Your AI conversations, preferences, and data all live in Google's cloud. This isn't paranoia—it's business strategy. Google wants you so integrated that leaving feels impossible. LazySusan is platform-agnostic. Use Google tools? Fine. Use Microsoft? Fine. Use nothing? Also fine. You're not signing up for a ecosystem—you're buying AI access.
What Gemini Can't Do
Despite Google's resources, Gemini still can't match specialized tools. Midjourney's image generation is more artistic. Claude's writing is more nuanced. GPT-5's coding is more practical. Gemini is a jack-of-all-trades, master of none—except Google integration. If you need the BEST tool for a specific task, Gemini is rarely it. It's the best tool if you need everything in Google, but that's a specific use case, not a universal one.
Privacy Considerations
Google's business model is data. Your Gemini conversations inform Google's understanding of you. Your AI usage patterns become part of your Google profile. For some people, this is fine—you're already in Google's ecosystem. For others, it's uncomfortable. LazySusan is an AI tool, not an advertising company. The relationship is simpler: you pay for AI, you get AI. No secondary monetization of your data.
The Honest Comparison
If you're all-in on Google—Gmail, Docs, Drive, Android, Chrome—Gemini Advanced is genuinely excellent value. The integration is seamless and powerful. But if you use any non-Google tools, or value platform independence, or want the best AI for each specific task rather than one AI for everything, LazySusan makes more sense. You get Gemini access AND Claude AND GPT AND specialized tools AND you're not married to any one company.
Our Verdict
Gemini Advanced is great AI wrapped in Google's strategic lock-in play. If you're already a Google power user, the integration is valuable. But for everyone else, you're trading flexibility for convenience. LazySusan gives you Gemini's capabilities PLUS Claude's writing PLUS GPT's coding PLUS specialized creative tools—without pledging allegiance to any single tech giant. Independence has value.
Get Access to Both (and 50+ More)
Why choose one AI when you can have them all? LazySusan gives you LazySusan, Gemini Advanced, and 50+ other premium AI tools for one low price.